Former President Donald Trump sparked close to common criticism final week when he stated that the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian award, was “significantly better” than the Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest award for army valor. Trump made these feedback throughout an occasion at his Bedminster, New Jersey, property about anti-Semitism, through which he was drawing consideration to the work of Miriam Adelson—the widow of his buddy, the on line casino magnate and megadonor Sheldon Adelson—who obtained the Medal of Freedom from Trump in 2018. Trump’s weird logic was that many recipients of the Medal of Honor are in “unhealthy form” due to their wounds or obtain the award posthumously, and that the Medal of Freedom is best as a result of a “wholesome, lovely girl” like Miriam Adelson can obtain it.
Through the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, I wrote quite a few citations for valor awards. Discerning whether or not actions comparable to rescuing a buddy from an ambush or assaulting an enemy place or main a daring raid are worthy of a Silver Star, Navy Cross, or, probably, the Medal of Honor is a novel problem. The primary time I needed to write up a valor award, I used to be a 24-year-old Marine second lieutenant in Fallujah. We had been in sustained house-to-house fight for 2 weeks when a directive got here down from our larger headquarters to start writing up our awards. The battle wasn’t even over. Marines have been nonetheless getting killed. Nonetheless, the sergeants and corporals in my platoon scribbled their suggestions on items of paper and I wrote them up between firefights on our firm’s single laptop computer, a Toughbook we stored charged with a gas-powered generator.
My firm commander on the time—a captain who, on the age of 30, appeared infinitely outdated and clever to me—defined his philosophy of writing awards. He advised that if I couldn’t determine whether or not a Marine deserved a Bronze Star, Silver Star, or one thing even larger, I ought to think about the day sooner or later once we would all stand in formation on the award’s presentation. He inspired me to intention for as excessive a valor award as potential, as long as nobody standing in formation would snicker below their breath that the award wasn’t deserved. This proved sound recommendation, which I hewed to through the years.
Valor awards acknowledge what was, possible, one of many worst days of somebody’s life. That is significantly true if an individual is being written up for the best awards—the Silver Star, Navy Cross, Air Pressure Cross, Distinguished Service Cross, or Medal of Honor. These usually are not given after a mission the place every little thing went proper and everybody got here house.
The method of approving these awards is arduous, and every of the providers handles it somewhat bit otherwise. The Marine Corps requires a “abstract of motion,” a prolonged doc that outlines intimately what occurred and why it deserves the award. That is adopted by a number of witness statements from those that noticed the actions of the awardee—many a hero has gone unsung as a result of no survivors existed to write down these witness statements. As soon as all of this documentation is gathered, it goes into an awards packet, which then circulates via a labyrinthine paperwork; at each degree of command, the award is both really useful for approval, downgraded, or, in some instances, upgraded. The nomination first travels to a battalion-level awards board. If accredited, it goes to the regiment. The method repeats because it circulates as much as division, and, within the case of the Marine Corps, to the Marine Expeditionary Pressure awards board, after which onward to Headquarters Marine Corps, adopted by the Workplaces of the Secretaries of the Navy and Protection, after which the White Home. Awards boards meet solely periodically, so this course of can take years. Valor awards usually are not bestowed by fiat.
Within the case of the Medal of Honor, recipients enter a particular fraternity. They turn out to be the embodiment of American valor, residing tributes to the heroism that exists deep in our nationwide character. It is a heavy burden, a star that, for a lot of, exacts a price and turns into a second sort of service. Audie Murphy, probably the most adorned soldier of the Second World Battle and a Medal of Honor recipient, struggled till his loss of life together with his personal psychological well being and with alcoholism. Extra not too long ago, post-9/11 Medal of Honor recipients comparable to Kyle Carpenter and Ryan Pitts have turn out to be vocal advocates for veterans and their psychological well being and reintegration.
When confronted with American valor, Trump has a historical past of constructing disparaging feedback, relationship way back to 2015 when he stated of the late Senator John McCain, a recipient of the Silver Star, that he “was solely a battle hero as a result of he was captured,” including, “I like individuals who weren’t captured, okay?” Maybe Trump thinks the Medal of Freedom is “higher” as a result of he, because the president, can award it to whomever he pleases, together with buddies and donors. The Medal of Honor affords him no such discretion. Additionally, it appears past his comprehension that an award might merely result in one other chapter of service and never turn out to be an accolade used for easy private benefit.
Throughout Trump’s presidency, he presided over 12 shows of the Medal of Honor. If he wins the White Home in November, he’ll possible preside over extra. I doubt anybody shall be saying at any future White Home presentation that an award wasn’t deserved. However they may say, as a substitute, that the person presenting it doesn’t deserve the distinction of performing the duty.
